How to Choose a Mid-Century (inspired) Kitchen Countertop

Read Without Interruptions

Subscribe to Mid-Century Home on Substack and enjoy our best content without ads.

American Standard catalogue via Retrorenovation.com

As you probably know, mid-century modern kitchens prioritised functionality and simplicity. They featured clean lines and open layouts, combining efficiency with a colourful and playful aesthetic.

Cabinets often had flat-front designs, using materials like walnut or metal. Built-in appliances and thoughtful storage solutions were common, keeping the space uncluttered.

Materials played also a key role in these kitchens, with countertops available in a variety of materials, colors and designs.

Laminate countertops, especially from the Formica manufacturer, were widely used for their durability and variety of colors and patterns, including boomerang and linen designs. 

Stainless steel was also popular, used for countertops, appliances, and edging, giving a sleek, industrial feel. For flooring, linoleum and vinyl were chosen for their resilience and easy maintenance, available in simple solids or lively patterns. Ceramic tiles were used for backsplashes and sometimes countertops, adding color and pattern to the kitchen.

These material choices reflected the era’s focus on practicality and a forward-looking design approach. Homeowners wanted kitchens that were both stylish and suited to the needs of modern living. Today, mid-century modern kitchens continue to inspire, blending design and material innovation in a timeless way.

But which materials and designs were popular back then and are still available today? Below, we’ve listed the most popular choices for mid-century kitchen countertops that you can still buy today. Each material offers unique characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages, which we’ve detailed to help you make an informed decision you won’t regret.  

Kitchen catalogue via Retrorenovation.com

Popular choices for mid-century kitchen countertops:

1. Laminate (Formica):

  • Composition: Layers of paper or fabric impregnated with resin, bonded under heat and pressure.
  • Advantages: Durable, affordable, and available in a wide range of colors and patterns, including iconic designs like boomerang and linen textures. 
  • Disadvantages: Susceptible to scratches and burns; edges could peel over time if not properly maintained.
  • Popularity Reasons: Its versatility allowed homeowners to achieve various design aesthetics, and it was easy to clean and maintain. 

2. Linoleum:

  • Composition: Natural materials such as linseed oil, wood flour, and cork dust.
  • Advantages: Eco-friendly, resilient, and offered in various colors and patterns.
  • Disadvantages: Prone to scratches and dents. RequireS regular sealing to protect against moisture and staining.
  • Popularity Reasons: Valued for its natural composition and matte appearance, suitable for both countertops and flooring.

3. Ceramic Tile:

  • Composition: Clay-based tiles glazed and fired at high temperatures.
  • Advantages: Heat-resistant and available in numerous colors and designs.
  • Disadvantages: Grout lines required regular maintenance to prevent staining and could harbor bacteria. Tiles could crack under heavy impact.
  • Popularity Reasons: Allowed for creative expression through patterns and was relatively easy to install.

4. Stainless Steel:

  • Composition: Alloy of steel with chromium, providing corrosion resistance.
  • Advantages: Sleek, modern appearance; heat and stain-resistant; hygienic and easy to clean.
  • Disadvantages: Prone to scratches and dents; could show fingerprints and smudges, requiring frequent cleaning to maintain appearance.
  • Popularity Reasons: Favored in modernist kitchens for its industrial look and durability.

5. Wood (Butcher Block):

  • Composition: Assembled strips of hardwood, such as maple or oak.
  • Advantages: Warm, natural appearance; gentle on dishware; could be sanded and refinished to remove scratches.
  • Disadvantages: Requires regular sealing to prevent moisture damage and bacterial growth; susceptible to scratches and dents.
  • Popularity Reasons: Provided a traditional, homey feel and was functional for food preparation.

6. Monel Metal:

  • Popularity Reasons: Offered a high-end, resilient countertop option, though less common due to higher cost. 
  • Composition: Alloy of nickel and copper.
  • Advantages: Rust-proof, resistant to food acids and alkalis, and durable.
  • Disadvantages: Less common due to higher cost; limited availability compared to other materials.

Tools You Might Need:

  • Circular Saw: Ideal for making straight cuts in countertop materials like laminate or butcher block. Ensure you have appropriate blades for the material you’re working with.
  • Jigsaw: Perfect for cutting curves or sink openings in your countertop. Its versatility makes it indispensable for intricate cuts.
  • Power Drill/Driver: Necessary for securing countertops to cabinets and attaching hardware. A cordless drill offers flexibility during installation.
  • Level: Ensures your countertop is perfectly horizontal, preventing issues with water drainage and appliance placement.
Mid-century kitchen countertop materials comparison table